CONSOLE VS CONSOLE / 5TH GENERATION · N64 TURNS 30 IN 2026

N64 vs PlayStation 1: Which Retro Console Is Worth Buying in 2026?

2026 marks the Nintendo 64's 30th anniversary — the perfect excuse to settle which 5th-gen console deserves a spot on your shelf first.

These two consoles solved the jump to 3D in almost opposite ways, and both solutions still hold up — just for different kinds of players.

Cartridges vs Discs: The Durability Question

This is the single biggest practical difference for a 2026 buyer. N64 cartridges have no moving parts, no laser to age out, and effectively don't degrade — a cart from 1996 works exactly like it did new, aside from needing a contact cleaning every so often. PS1 discs are a different story: the reflective layer can degrade over decades, and the console's laser assembly is a wearing part that eventually needs replacement or adjustment on original hardware. If "buy it once and never think about it again" matters to you, N64 has a real structural advantage.

The Library Trade-Off

PS1's disc format meant cheaper media and CD-quality audio, which is why its library is so much bigger and more varied — JRPGs, survival horror, and a genuinely enormous back catalog that N64 couldn't match cartridge-for-cartridge. N64, in exchange, got faster load times (instant, in most cases) and built-in four-player support on nearly every first-party game, which is why local multiplayer classics like GoldenEye, Mario Kart 64, and Mario Party still get pulled out for game nights in a way PS1's library rarely does.

Buying Advice for 2026

If you want one console for couch multiplayer and Nintendo's first-party output, start with N64 — and do it this year, while the 30th anniversary keeps the console in the conversation. If you want the deepest, most varied 32-bit library and don't mind budgeting for a disc-read service down the line, PS1 is the better single investment. Most serious collectors end up with both within a year or two of starting.

Some links on this page are eBay and Amazon affiliate links. If you buy through them, ShouldIBuyThisGame.com may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.