Saros vs Returnal: Which Should You Buy?
Housemarque's two third-person bullet-ballet roguelikes occupy almost the same shelf — same studio, same DNA, same DualSense magic. But they're not interchangeable. Saros (releasing April 30, 2026) is a deliberate evolution of Returnal's 2021 formula, not a remake or expansion. The right pick depends on what you actually want.
Here's the honest comparison.
Saros
Returnal
If you've never played Returnal, buy Returnal first ($30-40 on sale, available now). If you've already platinumed Returnal, pre-order Saros — it's evolved enough to feel fresh. If you want one PS5 roguelike at the lowest cost, Returnal wins on price. If you want the newest, sharpest version of this design philosophy, Saros wins.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Saros | Returnal | |
|---|---|---|
| Release | April 30, 2026 | April 30, 2021 |
| Platform | PS5 only | PS5 + PC |
| Price (new) | $69.99 | $59.99 (often $30-40 on sale) |
| Protagonist | Arjun Devraj (Rahul Kohli) | Selene Vassos |
| Setting | Carcosa — eclipse-ravaged alien planet | Atropos — psychological horror world |
| Run length | ~30 min (designed) | 1+ hour |
| Progression | Permanent upgrades after death | Mostly reset on death |
| Difficulty | Hard, with mitigation tools | Brutal, less forgiving |
| Tone | Cosmic mystery, action-forward | Cosmic horror, claustrophobic |
| Critic consensus | GOTY contender (early) | GOTY 2021 |
What Each Game Is
Saros
Saros is Housemarque's first major release since their 2021 acquisition by Sony. You play Arjun Devraj, a Soltari Enforcer hunting answers on the shape-shifting planet Carcosa. The big mechanical evolution is permanent progression — every death gives you upgrades and weapons that carry into your next run. Runs are designed for ~30-minute chunks instead of Returnal's marathon sessions, with shortcuts back to base after each boss. PS5 Pro support uses the latest PSSR upscaler with increased base render resolution at 60fps.
Returnal
Returnal launched in 2021 as Sony's first true PS5 showcase title. You play Selene, an astronaut crashed on the alien world Atropos, dying and returning over and over while the world rearranges itself. It won numerous Game of the Year awards and remains, for many critics and players, the best PS5 game in the catalog. The PC version released in 2023 with full ultrawide and graphics options. Five years on, it still benchmarks the bar for what DualSense haptics can do.
How to Decide
PICK SAROS IF...
- You played Returnal to completion and want more of that DNA, refined
- Permanent progression matters to you (Returnal's resets frustrated you)
- You own a PS5 Pro and want a brand-new showcase title
- 30-minute runs fit your schedule better than 1+ hour Returnal sessions
- You want the newest, most polished version of this design
PICK RETURNAL IF...
- You've never played Returnal — start here, it's $30-40 on sale right now
- You only have a PS5 (no Pro) and budget matters
- Cosmic horror atmosphere appeals to you more than action-mystery
- You want a game with established community resources and guides
- You play on PC — Saros isn't available there
The Bottom Line
Returnal is the safer financial bet and an objectively complete experience that's only gotten cheaper. Saros is the newer, sharper iteration with quality-of-life improvements (permanent progression, shorter runs, return to base after each boss) that address Returnal's main complaints — but at $70 and PS5-exclusive.
If you've never played either: buy Returnal now for $30-40, finish it, then decide if you want Saros at full price. If you loved Returnal: pre-order Saros. If you bounced off Returnal because runs felt too punishing, Saros's design changes are specifically for you.
Make Your Pick
Whichever way you go, here are the best places to buy:
SAROS ON AMAZON Also on eBay → RETURNAL ON AMAZON Also on eBay →As an Amazon Associate and eBay Partner we earn from qualifying purchases.
RELATED ON THE MANUAL
- Should You Pre-Order Saros? — Full Saros verdict
- Should You Buy Hades II? — Different roguelike, also great
- Best Roguelikes to Play in 2026